Tend to whenever times are given, he could be provided with 1 day of your day you to definitely really does perhaps not match with this day as it from inside the genuine background. One such example takes place in Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney describes 16 Oct due to the fact Saturday, in the event 16 October 1993 was a tuesday.

There are even contradictions from inside the guides here. Such as for instance, into the Harry Potter together with Goblet from Flame, one another step 1 September and you may 2 Sep are offered once the Mondays and you may, inside the Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner regarding Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is decided on the 20 April, but mindful parsing of the text message demonstrates that it might enjoys occurred no later on than just March.

Also, in Harry Potter and Cup off Flame they say that Champions was in fact selected on Tuesday 31 October, however, 31 Oct is actually a tuesday for the 1994.

Into the a bankruptcy proceeding regarding Quidditch Through the Age, it is said that the basic Quidditch Business Cup was held in 1473. If your tournament is actually kept all of the few years, that it conflicts towards the statement in Cup off Flames that 1994 Business Cup are the latest 422nd. If the Quidditch Through the Years is great, the latest 422nd Quidditch Industry Mug carry out in fact fall-in the entire year 3161, but if Cup out-of Fire is useful, the first World Cup got stored within the 306.

Historical troubles [ ]

Whilst collection, depending on the schedule derived from brand new Chamber away from Gifts resource, is decided from the nineties, the show commonly appears like it’s place in the newest late nineties so you’re able to middle-2000s, around concurrent for the guide of your own guides. Inside the Harry Potter and the 1 / 2 of-Blood Prince he has a good point, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to refer with the “predecessor” of your own Best Minister of your United kingdom. According to the more than timeline, this would occur in the summertime away from 1996, when the Primary Minister are John Major, whose instantaneous ancestor is actually a female (‘s the reason very first interviewing Fudge, the book says new election, but Big wasn’t first decided to go with and simply grabbed more immediately following Thatcher resigned.

You’ll be able to, yet not impractical, you to Fudge is talking about a far more distant ancestor, while the Thatcher got place of work in advance of Fudge allegedly turned into Minister to possess Miracle. (Although you can believe a situation in which Fudge is delegated by the Minister for Wonders to fulfill to the Perfect Minister as he, Fudge, was at an inferior work environment.) As well, the new personality and you may history of the prime Minister portrayed seems to a great deal more directly match compared to Tony Blair than just of John Significant. A post about Each day Mail notes one Rowling is intimate with the up coming-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brown (will seen as a competitor so you can Blair’s management of your own Work People, which succeeded your and you can became Prime Minister), which she could have been trying to reveal Blair’s worst front side. When your instructions was indeed devote connect which have guide date out of Philosopher’s Stone, next this knowledge manage occur in 2002 (immediately following Blair turned Finest Minister).

not, it absolutely was afterwards stated that 22 November is a friday, it was in 1994

A comparable situation comes to Nicolas Flamel, who was mentioned as actually 665 at the time of the brand new very first publication, but Nicolas Flamel is actually a bona fide historic figure and you may won’t have reached that age until 1996, inside the day the initial book was authored. The fresh rebuttal for this is the fact that time the fresh “real” Nicolas Flamel was created doesn’t talk to the latest Nicolas Flamel out of Harry Potter.

A separate state is present from Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure because the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s created regarding show one Hagrid was given you to definitely status in this a few years off his expulsion out of college during the 1942. However in you to world regarding Harry Potter while the Cup of Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces throughout the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap that have Molly’s decades at school, it seems unlikely one to she remembers a past gamekeeper. not, you are able one Hagrid didn’t end up being a gamekeeper immediately just after getting expelled, but instead started because the Ogg’s secretary. It is probable just like the when Harry thinks he will become expelled getting flying into broomstick rather than consent within his first 12 months, he miracle in the event the he would be permitted to remain on while the Hagrid’s assistant.